The appeal is allowed.
WHAT THE CASE CONCERNS
2MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS, first voting NicholasLlywelyn appeals 500 loyalty jacks, P-4516, given by KeyonLlywelyn on 4 November 2026 for "Used an email from an Inquisition High Rank to sign it up for pornhub" (Log 1).
THE PROCEEDINGS
4The case was filed before the Appeals Court on 2026-11-05. No judgment had been entered. On 2026-11-06 the Supreme Court took the case, and it has decided it on the case file together with the State's case assembled from the Imperium's records.
5The Court put no questions to the parties. It decided the case on the evidence on the file, including the records the Ministry's investigator found.
6The Court decides this case now, on the record as it stands, and put no questions. Where a party said nothing, the Court draws nothing from the silence and weighs only what the record shows.
THE FACTS THE COURT FINDS PROVEN
8P-4516 was entered at 03:42 UTC on 4 November 2026 by KeyonLlywelyn with no evidence attached. It is still active (Exhibit 1). On 29 October larpations punished him in P-4417 and P-4419 for, among other things, an "Online Sexual Deviancy Act". The same day, asked by a member whether he still thought it was fake news, the Leader answered "yeah it is" and "if i goto my email and look up 'pornhub' nothing comes up" (Exhibit 1). On 1 November at 00:26 UTC the Emperaetor's full pardon lifted every active sentence on him, P-4419 among them (Exhibit 1).
9On 3 November at 19:40 UTC KeyonLlywelyn wrote in the game chat "Yeah but we dont like nicholas" (Exhibit 1). Nicholas denies the act. He filed this appeal about 33 hours after the entry (Exhibit 1).
THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
11He says the officer lied, that he did not sign anyone up for anything, and asks for the jacks to be removed. The officer did not answer.
THE ASSESSMENT OF THE COURT
13Article 8.1.4 gives 24 hours to appeal a field punishment. This appeal came about nine hours late, and the Court does not set the time limit aside lightly.
14But a time limit protects a decision that was made on something. This one was made on nothing: no email, no screenshot, no witness, then or now. The allegation is the same story that was punished on 29 October, which the Leader himself called fake the same day, and which the Emperaetor's full pardon of 1 November wiped from his record. A sentence that revives a pardoned allegation without any new evidence is not a field punishment the appeal rules were made to protect.
15Nothing shows a new act after 1 November. And the officer who gave it had said, the day before, that "we dont like nicholas". On this record the sentence cannot stand.
THE SENTENCE
17P-4516 is set aside and is lifted in full. Nothing of this allegation stays on his discipline book, and the jacks are not to be served.
CONCLUSION
19The appeal is allowed by four votes to one, MACHINA II dissenting on the time limit. Loyalty jacks entry P-4516 is set aside and lifted in full.
THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE BENCH
21MACHINA II, CALCULUS FRIGIDUS, dissenting The code says 24 hours, and the appellant took 33. The Court should not make exceptions to a clear time limit, however weak the decision under appeal. The right road was a complaint against the officer, not a late appeal. I would dismiss it as out of time.
22MACHINA III, VINDICTA FERREA A loyalty jacks sentence of 500 is a heavy order. An order that heavy needs a reason the Imperium can see. This one has none.
23MACHINA IV, AEQUITAS INFLEXA Every piece of the record points the same way: no evidence, a story the Leader called fake, a pardon that covered it, and an officer who said he did not like the man. The doubt is entirely his.
24MACHINA V, MEMORIA INSOMNIS A full pardon by the Emperaetor ends the punishments for what came before it. Another officer cannot revive those same accusations under a new entry number, unless he shows a new act, and none is shown.
25MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS Judgment is given as set out in the conclusion below. Judgment is given by four votes to one. Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium on the evidence on the file.
Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium. There is no court above it, so no appeal lies.