Not guilty on 1.1.4 Failure to Comply.
WHAT THE CASE CONCERNS
2MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS, first voting The State charges OrthoValcroix with failure to comply under 1.1.4: six missed weekly quotas, a demotion that did not hold, and another miss after it (Log 1).
THE PROCEEDINGS
4The case was filed before the Imperial Prosecution Bureau on 2026-11-03. No judgment had been entered. On 2026-11-06 the Supreme Court took the case, and it has decided it on the case file together with the State's case assembled from the Imperium's records.
5The Court put no questions to the parties. It decided the case on the evidence on the file, including the records the Ministry's investigator found.
6The Court decides this case now, on the record as it stands, and put no questions. Where a party said nothing, the Court draws nothing from the silence and weighs only what the record shows.
THE FACTS THE COURT FINDS PROVEN
8The quota record shows misses in the weeks closing 27 September, 4, 11, 18 and 25 October and 1 November, with three events hosted in all, and system demotions on 11 and 25 October (Exhibit 1).
9On 20 October 2026 at 21:44 UTC misamiye, a Major General, promoted him from Master Lieutenant to Captain with the reason "active" (Exhibit 2). The system's demotion of 25 October took him from Captain back to Master Lieutenant (Exhibit 1). The roll of 3 November shows him a Master Lieutenant (Exhibit 3). He did not answer the summons and filed nothing.
THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
11The State asks for conviction, and asks that the quota demotion be restored as its sanction. He made no submission and gave no answer to the summons.
THE ASSESSMENT OF THE COURT
COUNT I, FAILURE TO COMPLY
14Article 1.1.4 punishes ignoring a lawful order from a superior. The weekly quota is such an order, and the misses are proven by the quota record (Exhibit 1).
15But the quota carries its own sanction. Two misses within four weeks bring a demotion of one rank, made by the system, and that sanction was applied to him (Exhibit 1). Punishing the same misses again here would punish one failure twice.
16The State's real complaint is that the demotion was undone. The rank book shows that it was undone by misamiye, not by him (Exhibit 2). Nothing on the file shows that he asked for it, deceived anyone to get it, or knew it was improper. A man is not guilty of another officer's act.
17The latest miss, in the week closing 1 November, falls to the quota system in the same way as the others. The count is not proven.
18In his case the restoration did not even last: the demotion of 25 October took the rank away again, and he holds the lower rank today.
CONCLUSION
20Not guilty under 1.1.4 by four votes to one. The misses were sanctioned by the quota system itself, and the restoration of his rank is not his act. Its lawfulness is left to the quota office and his command.
THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE BENCH
22MACHINA II, CALCULUS FRIGIDUS The charge is failure to comply. The failures are proven, but each met its own sanction, and the restoration is an act the article does not lay at his door.
23MACHINA III, VINDICTA FERREA, dissenting He kept a rank he had lost for missing the quota, and then missed it again. A man who takes back a rank he knows he has not earned shares in the wrong. I would convict and accept the demotion back as the State asked.
24MACHINA IV, AEQUITAS INFLEXA Nothing shows he asked for his rank back or knew it was wrong. The doubt is his.
25MACHINA V, MEMORIA INSOMNIS The Court does not punish a sanctioned failure again. Whether misamiye had the power to restore the rank is a question for the quota office and his own command, and nothing in this judgment protects that restoration.
26MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS Judgment is given as set out in the conclusion below. Judgment is given by four votes to one. Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium on the evidence on the file.
Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium. There is no court above it, so no appeal lies.