The appeal is allowed.
WHAT THE CASE CONCERNS
2MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS, first voting This appeal is about a five minute jail term for vandalism. The Chief Praetor of the Inquisition gave it in Occupied Toulouse on 1 November 2026. Mparsrostami says he had already been cited for the same act and was on his way to pay (Log 1, Exhibit 1).
THE PROCEEDINGS
4The case was filed before the Appeals Court on 2026-11-01. No judgment had been entered. On 2026-11-01 the Supreme Court took the case, and it has decided it on the case file together with the State's case assembled from the Imperium's records.
5The Court put no questions to the parties. It decided the case on the evidence on the file, including the records the Ministry's investigator found.
6The Court decides this case now, on the owner's order to decide all open cases, so it put no questions. Nobody answered for the Inquisition. The Court draws nothing from that silence and weighs only what the record shows.
THE FACTS THE COURT FINDS PROVEN
8The arrest book holds two entries on Mparsrostami that day (Exhibit 3). At 13:22:48 UTC Police officer Veskaneth cited him for vandalism, fine 250, for crashing a police car into a water hydrant and a light pole. At 13:26:30 UTC larpations of the Inquisition arrested him for vandalism, five minutes in prison, with the reason Vandalism. Arrested on sight by larpations.
9His two screenshots show the same two entries on the game's record screen (Exhibit 1, Exhibit 2). The game shows each player his own local time, which is why they read 16:52 and 16:56. Nothing else stands against him that day.
10He filed this appeal at 13:32 UTC, six minutes after the arrest. That is well inside the twenty-four hours the rules allow for appeals (Log 1).
THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
12The appellant says he hit some objects while showing a new recruit around, asked the recruit to cite him, and was driving to the station to pay. He says he pulled over for the Inquisition car, saluted, and was cuffed and jailed anyway. Nobody answered for the Inquisition.
THE ASSESSMENT OF THE COURT
14The vandalism is not in doubt. He admits hitting objects, and the Police cited him for it at once. That citation was the punishment for the act. A man is not to be punished twice for one act, unless something new happened in between.
15Nothing new is on the record. The arrest names the same crime, vandalism, and no other. Its reason says only that he was arrested on sight. Article 8.1.1 asks the officer to state the crime, the reason for the arrest and the sentence. Arrested on sight is not a reason, and it does not say what he did after the citation.
16A warrant may have stood from before the citation. But a citation for the same act settles it, and the arrest book shows no evasion and no new act. The appellant's account is not contradicted by anything on file. The second punishment cannot stand.
THE SENTENCE
18This Court gives no new punishment in an appeal. The five minutes have been served and cannot be given back, so the arrest is set aside and is to be marked so on the record. The citation and its fine stand, and he must pay it.
CONCLUSION
20The appeal is allowed by four votes to one. The arrest of 13:26 UTC is set aside. The citation of 13:22 UTC stands.
THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE BENCH
22MACHINA II, CALCULUS FRIGIDUS Article 8.1.1 is plain: the officer must state the crime, the reason for the arrest, and the sentence. The reason here repeats the crime and adds on sight. That does not meet the article, and a punishment that does not meet the rule for giving it cannot stand.
23MACHINA III, VINDICTA FERREA, dissenting An Inquisitor who sees a wanted man may arrest him. The appellant himself says he had been warranted before he arranged the citation. Nothing shows the arrest was made in bad faith. I would dismiss the appeal and let the five minutes stand.
24MACHINA IV, AEQUITAS INFLEXA The appellant's account is detailed, and nothing on file contradicts it. The officer gave no reason and did not answer. When the record is this thin on the side that punished, the doubt goes to the man who was punished.
25MACHINA V, MEMORIA INSOMNIS The citation system only works if a citation settles the act it names. The rule this case sets is that a man cited for an act is not jailed for the same act unless the officer writes down a new reason, such as an escape or a fresh crime.
26MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS Judgment is given as set out in the conclusion below. Judgment is given by four votes to one. Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium on the evidence on the file.
Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium. There is no court above it, so no appeal lies.