Not guilty on 4.1.5 Religious or Racial Discrimination, 4.1.1 Harassment, 1.1.4 Failure to Comply and 1.2.1 Desertion.
WHAT THE CASE CONCERNS
2MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS, first voting This is a State prosecution against KeyonLlywelyn for four counts under the Penal Code. The State asks for liquidation, mostly tied to an alleged public racial slur. The case also alleges a reposted election smear, ignoring an order about @everyone pings, and leaving offices without permission. The Court took the case under the seven day rule and must decide from the file alone. We decide each count on its own evidence.
THE PROCEEDINGS
4The case was filed before the Imperial Prosecution Bureau on 2026-10-27. No judgment had been entered. On 2026-10-31 the Supreme Court took the case, and it has decided it on the case file together with the State's case assembled from the Imperium's records.
5The Court put no questions to the parties. It decided the case on the evidence on the file, including the records the Ministry's investigator found.
6The Court did not put questions to the parties in this sitting. The file states the Court must decide now on the record as it stands. No answers were therefore received from either side. This means the Court must treat missing context as missing, and not guess what the missing messages said or showed.
THE FACTS THE COURT FINDS PROVEN
8The case was filed on 27 October 2026 and the Court took it on 31 October 2026. Log 3 shows the Supreme Court took the case and will decide it now. Exhibit 5 is a long extract of Discord messages with timestamps and channels. Exhibit 5 includes three @everyone pings on 13 December 2025 and a bot command saying “Never ping everyone again” on 24 August 2026. Exhibit 5 does not include the alleged 9 and 10 September 2026 posts.
THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
10The State says the defendant wrote the N word in public, reposted an insulting smear, pinged everyone after being told to stop, and deserted posts. The State relies mainly on Exhibit 1 to set out the exact words and on Exhibits 2 and 3 for duty and Senate voting. The defendant made no submission in the portal chat and filed no response in the record. The Court therefore decides from the State file and the exhibits only.
THE ASSESSMENT OF THE COURT
COUNT I, RELIGIOUS OR RACIAL DISCRIMINATION
13This count is about insulting or harassing someone based on race or similar traits. If a racial slur was posted publicly, that can fit this rule. But the rules on proof say the Court needs real evidence like a screenshot, video, or a witness statement of what happened. Exhibit 1 is a written quote file prepared for this case, and it is not the original Discord post. Exhibit 5 does not contain the alleged 10 September 2026 post. Count I is not proven.
COUNT II, HARASSMENT
15This count is about harassment, including insults against an organisation. The State says the defendant reposted a smear about the FFC on 9 September 2026. The problem is the same as Count I. Exhibit 1 states what the post allegedly said, but it is not the original message record. Exhibit 5 does not include the September 2026 message at all. With that gap, the Court cannot treat the allegation as proved. Count II is not proven.
COUNT III, FAILURE TO COMPLY
17This count is about ignoring a lawful order from a superior officer. Exhibit 5 proves the defendant pinged @everyone on 13 December 2025 and wrote “i know he said no more pings BUT.” That shows the defendant believed someone said to stop pings. But the record does not show who “he” was, what the exact order was, or that it was a lawful order from a superior over the defendant. Exhibit 5 also shows a bot command “Never ping everyone again,” but the count needs an order from authority. Count III is not proven.
COUNT IV, DESERTION
19This count is about leaving a division or leadership post without approval from a superior. The State relies on summaries in Exhibit 2 and Exhibit 3, and on some quoted lines in Exhibit 1. Exhibit 5 shows a development proclamation in December 2025 and a later message “I’m no longer a dev” on 30 July 2026. Those messages do not prove an actual resignation from a division or leadership post, and they do not show the lack of authorisation. The Senate voting list in Exhibit 3 is also a summary and does not show desertion as the code defines it. Count IV is not proven.
THE SENTENCE
21No count is proven. The Court therefore gives no punishment in this case. The plea offer in the filing does not change what the Court must decide, because the Court only sentences when a count is proven on evidence in the record.
CONCLUSION
23The State has not shown the key alleged September 2026 messages for Counts I and II. For Count III, the State has shown pings but not a clear lawful order from a superior that was ignored. For Count IV, the State has shown partial statements and summaries but not an unauthorized leaving of a division or office. The defendant is therefore found not guilty on all counts.
THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE BENCH
25MACHINA II, CALCULUS FRIGIDUS I read the code words closely for each count. For 4.1.5 and 4.1.1, the act must be shown as an actual insult or harassment in the Octavian sphere. A written quote file is not the same as the post itself. For 1.1.4, the act must be ignoring a lawful order from an authority the defendant is under. “He said no more pings” does not identify an authority or the exact order.
26The strongest point for the State is that Exhibit 5 looks like a real archive and shows the defendant did ping. Still, the legal element is the ignored order, not the ping by itself. For 1.2.1, desertion is leaving a division or staff post without authorisation. A line like “I’m no longer a dev” does not prove the role status change or the lack of permission. I vote NOT GUILTY on all counts.
27MACHINA III, VINDICTA FERREA The alleged conduct, if proved, would be serious. A public racial slur harms discipline and breaks trust fast. I would not hesitate to support harsh sanctions if the post was proven. But the Court must punish only what is shown clearly in the file, and the file does not contain the actual September posts. A summary of words is not enough when liquidation is asked.
28On the ping count, the archive shows repeated @everyone pings, which is disruptive. Still, the count is failure to comply, not disorderly conduct. The missing part is the clear order, by a superior, directed to this defendant. On desertion, the record shows inconsistency, but not the clean proof of an unauthorized resignation. I therefore vote NOT GUILTY on all counts, with no sentence.
29MACHINA IV, AEQUITAS INFLEXA This case shows why context matters. Exhibit 1 and Exhibit 2 read like prosecutor notes, not the underlying messages. Exhibit 5 is closer to primary evidence, but it stops before the key September items for Counts I and II. That creates a real doubt about whether the alleged slur and repost happened as charged, and we must not fill the gaps ourselves.
30Count III also has doubt. The defendant’s own words imply someone said “no more pings,” but we do not know who, or whether that person had authority over him. The bot command is not enough to show a lawful order from a superior. Count IV is even less complete. It does not show the defendant left a division role, and it does not show refusal of permission. I vote NOT GUILTY on all counts.
31MACHINA V, MEMORIA INSOMNIS The Court should keep a steady rule for later cases: when the charge rests on a specific Discord message, the file should include that message in a reliable form. Exhibit 5 meets that style, with timestamps and channels, but it does not contain the messages needed for Counts I and II. Deciding guilt from a prepared quote list would make later cases uneven and unsafe.
32The earlier case list shows that slur cases can lead to strong outcomes, but only when the act is properly shown in the record. Here, the strongest proven items are the December 2025 pings, yet the charged rule is about disobeying a lawful superior order. Without proof of the order and the superior relationship, conviction would slide into guesswork. I vote NOT GUILTY on all counts.
33MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS Judgment is given as set out in the conclusion below. The Court is unanimous. Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium on the evidence on the file.
Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium. There is no court above it, so no appeal lies.