JUDICIAL MINISTRY · THE SUPREME COURT
ALL DECISIONSCASE FILETHE MINISTRY
Judgement of the Supreme Court

The State v TristanGHorrigan

JMO-0091 · 2026-10-31 · Failure to Comply · 32 paragraphs
The judgement
1.1.4 · NOT GUILTY 1.1.2 · NOT GUILTY
Not guilty on 1.1.4 Failure to Comply and 1.1.2 Disrespect of a Lawful Officer.
Sentence. None. No punishment was imposed.
InstanceSupreme Court of the Imperium of Octavium
Date2026-10-31
PublishedJMO-0091
Keywordsmadrid arrest · stuka bombing chat log · no captured order · no captured disrespect words
Procedural historyFiled 2026-10-27 before the Supreme Court. Taken by the Supreme Court on the evidence on the file on 2026-10-31. No questions to the parties. Decided on the papers by the Machina Bench sitting five on 2026-10-31.
PartiesClaimant: The State
Respondent: TristanGHorrigan
BenchThe Machina Bench · ARBITER PERPETUUS presiding
CitedOctavian Penal Code 1.1.2, 1.1.4.

WHAT THE CASE CONCERNS

2
MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS, first voting This case is about what happened in Madrid on 30 September 2026 after a Stuka bombing. The State says the respondent ignored Inquisition orders and disrespected the Inquisition while being arrested. The respondent has filed no answer in the case file, and there is no portal chat. The Court must decide only on what is in the exhibits, logs, and recorded messages in this file.

THE PROCEEDINGS

4
The case was filed before the Supreme Court on 2026-10-27. No judgment had been entered. On 2026-10-31 the Supreme Court took the case, and it has decided it on the case file together with the State's case assembled from the Imperium's records.
5
The Court put no questions to the parties. It decided the case on the evidence on the file, including the records the Ministry's investigator found.
6
The Court asked no questions. The sitting instruction says the Court must decide now on the record as it stands. The Court therefore decides only on the file materials already listed. Sitting instruction, Procedure so far section.

THE FACTS THE COURT FINDS PROVEN

8
The Madrid game chat log shows Inquisition messages asking why someone bombed everyone. The log also shows, "We have tristian arrested." The log also says the Inquisition could not see his chats for some reason. The log contains no message from Tristan in the shown window. Exhibit 2.
9
The punishment book shows entry P-4075 filed by larpations on 30 September 2026. It lists "Refusal to comply with Inquisition orders" and "disrespect of the Inquisition" with 40 jacks served. The entry does not quote any order or any disrespectful words. Exhibit 3.
10
The re-education record shows that on 27 October 2026 larpations sentenced Tristan to Course IV, OBEDIENCE, and listed P-4075 as the grounds. Exhibit 5. The State record search also contains a later Discord message by Tristan saying "L larpations". State message 2026-10-30T18:51:09.524000+00:00.

THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES

12
The State says the Inquisition had power to give lawful orders, and that Tristan refused them during the Madrid incident. The State also says he disrespected the Inquisition during the arrest. The State relies mainly on the discipline entry and the later OBEDIENCE course tied to it. Filing, Exhibit 3, Exhibit 5.
13
The respondent has not submitted any plea, explanation, or evidence in this case file. Nothing was said in the portal chat. Procedure so far section, portal chat section.

THE ASSESSMENT OF THE COURT

COUNT I, FAILURE TO COMPLY

16
Failure to Comply means ignoring a lawful order from an authority you are under. Here, the Madrid chat log shows an arrest and questions about the bombing. It does not show a clear order directed to Tristan, like a command to land, stop, surrender an item, or answer a question. Exhibit 2, Penal Code 1.1.4.
17
The punishment book entry uses the words "refusal to comply," but it does not tell the Court what the order was or how Tristan refused it. Without the order and the refusal, this count is not proven on this record. Tristan is therefore not guilty on Count I. Exhibit 3, Penal Code 8.1.2.

COUNT II, DISRESPECT OF A LAWFUL OFFICER

19
Disrespect of a Lawful Officer means communicating genuine disdain that an officer can perceive. The State ties this count to what Tristan said during the 30 September arrest. The Madrid chat log does not include any message from Tristan in the relevant time window. Exhibit 2, Penal Code 1.1.2.
20
The punishment book entry states "disrespect of the Inquisition," but it does not quote the words or describe the act. A later Discord insult toward larpations is not the charged time and place. This count is not proven on this record. Tristan is therefore not guilty on Count II. Exhibit 3, State message 2026-10-30T18:51:09.524000+00:00, Penal Code 8.1.2.

CONCLUSION

22
TristanGHorrigan is not guilty on Count I and not guilty on Count II. The record does not show the missing details needed to match the charged offences. This judgment does not decide whether other uncharged offences occurred in Madrid.

THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE BENCH

24
MACHINA II, CALCULUS FRIGIDUS Count I requires a lawful order and an ignored order. The chat log shows questions and an arrest, not an order and a refusal. The discipline entry is only a summary label without the order or refusal. That does not satisfy the article’s own wording. Exhibit 2, Exhibit 3.
25
Count II requires a communicated act or message that shows disdain. The only Madrid log in the file shows no message from the respondent. The later Discord insult exists, but it is outside the charged arrest. The elements are not met for either count. I vote not guilty on both.
26
MACHINA III, VINDICTA FERREA This file describes a bombing that killed senior figures. That kind of harm demands discipline when proven. But the State did not charge bombing here, and we cannot punish it under these counts. Exhibit 2.
27
On the charged counts, the record lacks the direct order, the direct refusal, and the direct disrespectful words. Punishment without those facts risks punishing the wrong act. That weakens order instead of strengthening it. I vote not guilty on Count I and Count II, and no sentence.
28
MACHINA IV, AEQUITAS INFLEXA The State’s own exhibit says Tristan’s chat was not captured in the Madrid log. That creates a large hole because both charges depend on his words or conduct at that moment. Exhibit 2.
29
A short discipline entry can be honest, but it is not enough by itself to remove doubt about what was ordered and what was said. The later Discord insult does not prove what happened during the arrest. With these gaps, fairness requires not guilty on both counts.
30
MACHINA V, MEMORIA INSOMNIS Convictions for refusal to comply usually rest on a record showing the order and the refusal, such as clear logs. Here we only have an arrest line and a later discipline label. That is not a safe standard for future cases. Exhibit 2, Exhibit 3.
31
If we upheld these charges on this record, later cases could treat any short punishment note as enough. That would create inconsistent results and weak records. The stable rule is simple, show the order and the refusal, and show the disrespect words. I vote not guilty on both.
32
MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS Judgment is given as set out in the conclusion below. The Court is unanimous. Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium on the evidence on the file.
The conclusion of the Court
  1. TristanGHorrigan is found not guilty on count 1.1.4 Failure to Comply.
  2. TristanGHorrigan is found not guilty on count 1.1.2 Disrespect of a Lawful Officer.
  3. No sentence is imposed.
  4. Unanimous.

Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium. There is no court above it, so no appeal lies.

The official ruling of the Judicial Ministry of Octavium · no sign-in is needed to read it
The Machina Bench · ARBITER PERPETUUS presiding
The complete case file